Butler Bay

Butler Bay has 3 active listings and the average listing price is $1,546,000. The typical home in Butler Bay has 4.3 beds, 3.3 baths, and is 3,374.3 SqFt. Land-only listings are excluded to provide accurate averages for price, size, beds, and baths

Price

Beds

Baths

Filters

Reset

Basic Info

Price

Beds

Baths

Property Type

Sold Date

Days Sold

Advanced

Less Than

Land Tenure

Unit Level

In-Law Suite

Property Details

SqFt

Switch to Acre

Lot Size

Switch to Acre

Year Built

Stories

Kitchens

Flooring

Special Listing Condition

Pool

HOA Y/N

Amenities

Level(s)

Fence

Property Sub Type

Ownership

Adult Community

Basement

Suite

Exterior Finish

Financing

Other Rooms

Acres

Style

Water Front Y/N

Association Fee Include

Foundation

Bedroom Description

Full Bathrooms

Half Bathrooms

Minimum Lease Period

House Faces

Furnished

Restrictions

Pets

Construction

Frontage

Pet Allowed

Property Condition

Water Access

Water Access Features

New Construction Y/N

Utilities

Tax Amount

Short Sale(Y/N)

Architectural Style

Water

Laundry

Roof

Listing Terms

Building Type

Bathroom Description

Unit Features

Basement(Y/N)

CDD Y/N

Land Lease Fee

Fireplace Y/N

Keyword

Flood Zone

Assessed Value

Interior Features

Interior Lot Features

Appliances

Exterior Features

Lot Description

Garage Type

Parking Type

Parking Space

Garage Space

Carport Spaces

Exterior Features

Pool Y/N

Garage Y/N

Attached Garage(Y/N)

Gulf Access Type

Patio and Porch Features

Property Features

Waterfront

Community Features

Exposure

Water View

Golf Type

Other Structures

Lake Name

Views

Has Picture

Save Snapshot

View Results

MARKET SNAPSHOT

(OCT 03, 2026 - NOV 02, 2026)

Refine Search

?

Sold Listings
?

Average Sales Price
?

Average Days on Market

Market Trends

(Nov 2025 - Oct 2026)

Please input a valid location in the search bar to view the local market trends.

RECENT LISTINGS

Sold

Active

Active Under Contract

Back on Market

Coming Soon

Contingent

New

Pending

Price Changed

Reactivated

Sold

Under Contract

__MIGRATION_CONFLICT__

2617 BUTLER BAY DR N, Windermere, FL 34786

Single Family Home

$1,450,000

$199K

2617 BUTLER BAY DR N, Windermere, FL 34786

4 Beds
4 Baths
3,086 SqFt

Listing Provided By COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

2428 BUTLER BAY DR N, Windermere, FL 34786

Single Family Home

$1,115,000

$35K

2428 BUTLER BAY DR N, Windermere, FL 34786

4 Beds
4 Baths
3,387 SqFt

Listing Provided By COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

Unlock Recent Listings